La Otra Escena: Claves de lo Imaginario by Octave Mannoni - A Review

La Otra Escena: Claves de lo Imaginario by Octave Mannoni - A Review

La Otra Escena: Claves de lo Imaginario (The Other Scene: Keys to the Imaginary) is a book by French psychoanalyst and philosopher Octave Mannoni, published in 1973. In this book, Mannoni explores the role of the imagination in human psychology, especially in relation to the unconscious, fantasy, and desire. He argues that the imagination is not a mere faculty of representation, but a creative force that shapes reality and reveals hidden aspects of ourselves and others.

Octave Mannoni La Otra Escena Pdf Downloadl

Mannoni draws on various sources, such as Freudian psychoanalysis, Lacanian theory, anthropology, literature, and art, to illustrate his thesis. He analyzes different forms of the imaginary, such as dreams, myths, jokes, fairy tales, magic, and cinema. He also examines the paradoxes and contradictions of the imaginary, such as the phenomenon of "I know very well, but nevertheless", which he calls "the other scene". This is the gap between what we consciously know and what we unconsciously believe or desire.

La Otra Escena is a stimulating and original work that offers a rich and nuanced perspective on the human psyche. It is also a challenging and complex book that requires some familiarity with psychoanalytic concepts and terminology. However, for those who are interested in exploring the depths of the imagination and its relation to reality, this book is a valuable and rewarding read.

If you want to download La Otra Escena in PDF format, you can find it online at various websites. However, we recommend that you buy a copy from a reputable bookstore or online retailer to support the author and publisher.

In this review, we will focus on one of the main themes of Mannoni's book: the role of the other scene in the formation of the imaginary. The other scene is a concept that Mannoni borrows from Freud, who used it to refer to the hidden stage of the unconscious where our repressed wishes and fantasies are enacted. Mannoni expands this concept to include not only the individual unconscious, but also the collective and cultural unconscious. He argues that the other scene is the key to understanding the dynamics of the imaginary, which he defines as "the ensemble of images and symbols that constitute our mental life" (Mannoni 1973, 9).

Mannoni shows how the other scene operates in various domains of human experience, such as art, religion, science, politics, and psychoanalysis. He demonstrates how the other scene reveals aspects of ourselves and others that are normally hidden or denied by our conscious ego. He also explores how the other scene can be a source of creativity and transformation, as well as a cause of conflict and misunderstanding. He illustrates his arguments with examples from literature, mythology, anthropology, history, and his own clinical practice.

One of the most interesting and original contributions of Mannoni's book is his analysis of the colonial situation as a manifestation of the other scene. He argues that colonization is not only a political and economic phenomenon, but also a psychological and imaginary one. He shows how both colonizers and colonized are influenced by their unconscious fantasies and projections about each other. He identifies two typical complexes that characterize the colonial situation: the Prospero complex and the Caliban complex.

The Prospero complex is named after the protagonist of Shakespeare's The Tempest , who is a powerful magician and ruler of an island where he enslaves a native named Caliban. Mannoni argues that this complex affects those colonizers who have an unresolved father complex, which makes them flee from their own culture and seek a paternal authority in a foreign land. They project their own repressed desires and fears onto the colonized, whom they treat as inferior and savage. They also use their superior technology and knowledge as a form of magic to dominate and manipulate them.

The Caliban complex is named after Prospero's slave, who is a rebellious and resentful creature who hates his master. Mannoni argues that this complex affects those colonized who have an ambivalent attitude towards their colonizers. They depend on them for their material and cultural needs, but they also despise them for their arrogance and oppression. They internalize their colonizers' image of them as primitive and inferior, but they also resist it by asserting their own identity and culture. They also use their own forms of magic and religion to challenge and subvert their colonizers' authority. e0e6b7cb5c